Monthly Archives: June 2013

Entity Framework 6 and Async

At a previous company that I worked for, one of my colleagues, Paul Czywczynski referred to Entity Framework as “Database Crack”. I can see where he was coming from. There is no substitute for a database developer who knows how to write a Common Table Expression. These days however, to be a well-rounded back-end developer, you’re a step ahead of the rest if you can write your own SQL code. Entity Framework is great for getting up and going quickly. The dynamic query generation is much better today than it was just a few years ago. Code-First has come a long way, especially with the introduction of Database Migrations.

The Task Parallel Library (TPL) is good. Async is great. Await is even better.

Recently, the EF team has brought asynchronous operations to the EF API. You now see extension methods for everything that executes a query; FirstOrDefaultAsync, SingleAsync, ToListAsync, etc… AWESOME right?

Not so fast…

Check this out, directly from the EF 6 Codeplex site:

For the moment, EF will detect if the developer attempts to execute two async operations at one time and throw.

Basically what this is saying, is that you cannot access the result of an async operation until you have awaited the previous. Doesn’t that effectively defeat the power and purpose of async operations in EF? I believe the problem at hand is that DbContext or ObjectContext is not thread safe. In other words, because EF manages change tracking behind the scenes, making it async is a no-no. If you change something on one thread, what happens to that object on the other thread? This is not a problem that I personally want to solve, but I hope that someone at Microsoft does. If they truly want to make the EF 6 API async, then they must tackle this as well.

These days, Microsoft is making their newer API’s task based. My advice to anyone reading this, is that if you are developing against the Microsoft stack, it would greatly benefit you to brush up on your async skills.

*** UPDATE ***

I filed a “bug” on the CodePlex site last week regarding this. Technically, it wasn’t a bug, but I wanted to see what they would say: CodePlex Entity Framework Work Item #1279